If you are an attorney, you may have heard the phrase “what does plead the 5th day in court?” But what does this mean? It is a question of what will be admitted as evidence in a court of law. The phrase came about because of a common practice that arose in common court and criminal courts where defendants would plead the fifth day in court. The idea was that if the defendant could not appear in court, that evidence against them would not be used against them. This practice did not take off, however, and in most jurisdictions, it is now dead.
However, there is a different type of evidence: that can be used in courts other than what does plead the fifth day in court. In fact, this type of evidence can involve a great deal more than what does plead the fifth day in court. In many cases, it is hearsay evidence that is admitted into the courtroom.
Hearsay is defined as statements: oral statements, or representations made to a third person that is not reliable, true, and timely made. Thus, if someone says something to another person, it is hearsay evidence. This type of evidence can be damaging to the defendant, especially if it is true. It can help the prosecution build a case when statements are admitted into the courtroom and statements are allowed to be repeated by various sources. The statements should be carefully documented and should accurately describe events that occurred during the time frame in which they were said.
There are some defenses to what does plead the 5th day in court: but they do not hold up in court. Fabricating evidence is something that defense lawyers will try to use in court. This is usually used by drug or alcohol related crimes. However, there is a very big exception to this rule and that is when a person is guilty of something that does not actually involve drugs or alcohol. For example, fabricated testimony by a police officer about the use of illegal drugs can be used against an individual.
Another argument for what does plead the 5th day in court: is the issue of establishing a motive for the crime. This is important because if the prosecution can prove that the defendant intended to commit a certain act, it is essential for the jury to know why the act was done. The hearsay evidence argument is very popular with prosecutors because it is easy to demonstrate the intent behind a crime. However, if there is no proof tying the defendant to the commission of the crime, the prosecutor has a difficult time making a convincing argument for what does plead the 5th day in court.
What does plead the 5th day in court is a very subjective thing: Many times, the law will follow the personality of the person who is being charged. Sometimes, the jury will want to take a chance and acquit a person of a crime. On the other hand, sometimes the judge may not grant a motion for a jury trial.
In these cases, what does plead the 5th day in court is up to the jury to decide.
-
Previous Post
What Does N/A Mean?